Universities’ Soviet style PR will be saved by social media – Part I

The most discussed subject in university board meetings, after finance and capital projects of course, is most likely to be communication and its connection to public relations. Universities know that they are failing at it, yet they don’t seem to know what to do. I will argue here and in the next two posts that Social Media can and will reverse this situation as universities have now the potential to shape and even dominate the news circuit. Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds | 5 Comments

PPP: Plagiarism, Philanthropy and Politics

Last September, I received a request to referee a mathematics paper that was submitted for publication to a serious European journal.  I admit that I detest when such requests arrive, but …. the editor-in-chief is a friend that I admire very much, so I obliged. Fortunately, the job was a piece of cake. Here was my report: Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds | 1 Comment

The Kafkaesque grip of bureaucrats on Canada’s peer review and granting process

The observer couldn’t believe what she was hearing as she watched one of the subgroups consisting of 5 panelists in NSERC’s new conference model. “The applicant has a couple of papers in the Journal of … . Does anyone know anything about this journal?” said one. “Oh this must be one of these obscure journals”, replied another panelist. Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 13 Comments

Which bureaucracies will survive the new media age?

Tony Clement tweeted the government’s opposition to the latest CRTC ruling on usage-based billing for Internet services. I may have learned about it before his Public Affairs department did. Everyone talks about Wikileaks and the role of social media in the recent changes in Tunisia and Egypt. The (neo)-Kremlin seems to be making plans to prevent a Facebook revolution. Are bureaucracies, which normally hold together governments, corporations and university administrations ready for the inevitable assault of the new media age on their fortresses? ->

Posted in Op-eds | 5 Comments

Is your body simply a means of transport for your head?

Michelle did it again the other day. I was in a meeting in Toronto when I received her text message:  “As a university professor, do you consider your body to be simply a means of transport for your head?” I replied “yes” with no hesitation. It took me much longer to analyze later why did I do so, and may probably require many sessions of psychoanalysis to understand why.
Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

21 upcoming “Pieces of Mind”

Here are some of the issues I will be posting on in the next few weeks – not necessarily in the order below. Some are ready, others need to be polished and analysed further. Please chip in if you will. Your submissions will be most welcome.  More on how you can help us inform the academic community follows at the bottom of the post. Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

NSERC … A Senior Scientist Speaks Out

Don Fraser, Professor Emeritus at the University of Toronto has taught and trained several generations of Canadian statisticians, and he is still at it. He also continues to contribute high-level research. He was –as recently as last summer– an invited speaker at the Joint Statistical Meetings in Vancouver, attended by more than 4000 statisticians. Don has been stonewalled by NSERC’s bureaucracy and he has decided to speak out. Make sure not to miss the epilogue! Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds | 10 Comments

Guest Blogger John B. Walsh: Insidious buzzwords and all that jazz

Nassif Ghoussoub needs your help. Every time I go into his office to tell him what he should blog about, he simply tells me to write it myself. He is obviously desperate. Let me tell you how desperate he is.

This is what we discussed the last time I visited him.
Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds | 3 Comments

The Brand-Free Advantage-A student’s take

Submitted by a UBC student who wishes to remain anonymous

How would you describe Canada’s Universities in a few words? U of T is huge, traditional, well established, and therefore academically credible. McGill’s where the party is at and located in the “coolest” city. Concordia is a lesser McGill with a lot of protesters. The University of Calgary is incredibly average, quite cold, and yet somehow important because it’s in Alberta. UVic is rabbits and drinking, as well as a safe ferry-ride away from parents of Vancouver-native students. Queens is engineers with purple jackets and guarantees a fun time. UBC is… is… hmmm…that’s a good question, what is UBC? Asian? Rain? But these are Vancouver’s stereotypes. Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds | Leave a comment

Faculty representation: Here we go again!

A few weeks ago,  in an exceptionally professional and selfless act, Darrin Lehman declined to take his position as a faculty representative on the UBC Board of Governors. This is because of the potential conflict with his current administrative position as Senior Associate Dean.  Now we learn that another Associate Dean has decided to be a candidate in the runoff election to replace Darrin.
Continue reading

Posted in Board of Governors | 1 Comment

Assessing Science is hard! NSERC bureaucrats should know it, but then so do we!

Dozens of Canadian scientists are now back home from Ottawa after a week of “grant selecting” at NSERC. Many are self-satisfied by their 5 days of empowerment (the “Ottawa power trip”?). Others are embittered by the ever-tightening bureaucratic grip on Canada’s science evaluation and granting.
Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds | 4 Comments

A maverick on the Board of Governors? You ain’t seen nothing yet

Please meet Joe Peek, the faculty who was recently elected trustee on the University of Kentucky Board. “Now that you have foolishly elected me as your faculty trustee, I have lost all respect for you, thereby fully qualifying me to be a UK trustee. Therefore, it is time for me to tone down the campaign rhetoric, take on a more statesperson-like role, and stop making cheap jokes at the expense of the UK administration. … Yeah, right.”
Continue reading

Posted in Board of Governors | 1 Comment

20 years of NSERC funding for Discovery

Many thanks again to Queen’s Professor, David Wehlau for rummaging with NSERC’s search engine to come up with very useful historical data for the funding of the Discovery Grants program. David was of course interested in the historical trends for the mathematical sciences (the numbers don’t look very pretty there –see Table at bottom). But he was kind enough to prepare the two following tables so that we can learn more about the global picture. Continue reading

Posted in R&D Policy | Leave a comment

UBC and U of T: A tale of two student housing initiatives

Last week, both UBC and the University of Toronto announced major plans to increase student housing opportunities on their campuses. Two completely different approaches, both motivated by the same determination to “go even more global”, and by their respective government’s policies not to fund student housing projects. Compared to U of T’s plan and the way it was communicated, UBC’s comes out smelling of roses. Rightly so. Continue reading

Posted in Board of Governors, UBC Housing Action Plan | Leave a comment

Knowledge and Economics require different measuring sticks

Invention and Innovation are obviously closely interrelated.  But innovation is about economics, while discovery and invention are about knowledge. Innovation is about now, discovery is about now and the future. The problems arise when we start using the same measuring stick (or is it STIC?) and the same time scale to evaluate their respective successes and failures. The brilliant Chinese “fast follower” innovation has been extremely successful, but it has nothing to do with Chinese support for R&D.
Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 5 Comments

Psst! Pass it on! Concerns about NSERC’s ways

An NSERC evaluation group member “who would like to remain in the background” has forwarded the following memo to a colleague “who should remain anonymous” asking him if  he would forward it to the “Piece of Mind” blog. Is this how social media managed to topple the Tunisian and Egyptian bureaucracies dictatorships? Continue reading

Posted in R&D Policy | 2 Comments

Tea partying is busting the NSF budget

US House Republicans released a continuing resolution (CR) bill proposing to cut $100B from FY11 budget. How did the National Science Foundation (NSF) fare?
Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 1 Comment

Are headhunting firms shaping the leadership of Canada’s universities?

Executive search agencies, also known as headhunters, are now engaged in the recruitment of most senior administrators in Canadian universities. How important is their influence on the pool of academic leaders, and are they worth their cost?
Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds | 1 Comment

Innovate or perish? Not so fast

Kevin Lynch is back lecturing in the Financial Post on what Canada’s researchers need to do to solve the country’s economic woes, and reminiscing about his own days in government, when he was essentially running the country’s S&T agenda before Clement and Goodyear took over that show. The analysis is not original and the rhetoric hasn’t changed. Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 3 Comments

Buying $190 million worth of excellence

At the invitation of U. Alberta’s President, Indira Samarasekera, the who’s who of Canada’s political, business, academic, and media elite converged yesterday on the Fairmont Chateau Laurier in Ottawa to celebrate the establishment of the Canada Excellence Research Chair Program (CERC). The official invitation begins with, “Thanks to the CERC program, 19 of the world’s best researchers have chosen Canada”. The most fun speech of the night was given by one of the chair holders. “I’m told, I am not supposed to say that I came here for the money”!

Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 4 Comments