Category Archives: R&D Policy

When Orwell meets Baden-Powell at the NRC

Alberta Research Council culture goes National! Over the course of his 12-year tenure as President and CEO of the Alberta Research Council (ARC), John McDougall steered the organization towards “delivering and aligning science and technology solutions to industry’s needs”. Less … Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 2 Comments

A business dean’s rant: Ignorance of the facts or pure “Chutzpah”?

“What makes a country prosperous is not investment in science and technology. It is businesses producing high paying jobs by having unique products and processes that a customer needs”. This is from Roger Martin, a former management consultant, who is … Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 7 Comments

Who is shredding SR&ED?

The fattest course on the menu of Canada’s federal support for R&D is SR&ED, the $4-billion “Scientific Research and Experimental Development” tax credit program. So many people have been beating on SR&ED lately, which make you wonder whether it still have … Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 6 Comments

The University as a New Media superpower

Mainstream media institutions, which traditionally dominate the communication channels, often need to solicit and buy “content”, whether it is news or analysis. On the other hand, universities, which sit on, and constantly generate, a wealth of information and “content” must … Continue reading

Posted in Board of Governors, Op-eds, R&D Policy | 3 Comments

Who is standing up for Canada’s basic research?

Innovation is “not a linear progression of basic science into new products“. It requires “patience, persistence and investment”. This is from a call from the League of European Research Universities for the European Union to make substantial long-term investments in … Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 7 Comments

Tri-council continues to move funds from discovery to industry

Here we go again! A headline from the latest NSERC-Contact newsletter. CREATE adds industrial and international opportunities “The CREATE program will have two new dimensions in the 2012 competition. In keeping with NSERC’s goal to give students the opportunity to learn … Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 9 Comments

The Kafkaesque grip of bureaucrats on Canada’s peer review and granting process

The observer couldn’t believe what she was hearing as she watched one of the subgroups consisting of 5 panelists in NSERC’s new conference model. “The applicant has a couple of papers in the Journal of … . Does anyone know … Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 13 Comments

20 years of NSERC funding for Discovery

Many thanks again to Queen’s Professor, David Wehlau for rummaging with NSERC’s search engine to come up with very useful historical data for the funding of the Discovery Grants program. David was of course interested in the historical trends for … Continue reading

Posted in R&D Policy | Leave a comment

Knowledge and Economics require different measuring sticks

Invention and Innovation are obviously closely interrelated.  But innovation is about economics, while discovery and invention are about knowledge. Innovation is about now, discovery is about now and the future. The problems arise when we start using the same measuring … Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 5 Comments

Psst! Pass it on! Concerns about NSERC’s ways

An NSERC evaluation group member “who would like to remain in the background” has forwarded the following memo to a colleague “who should remain anonymous” asking him if  he would forward it to the “Piece of Mind” blog. Is this … Continue reading

Posted in R&D Policy | 2 Comments

Tea partying is busting the NSF budget

US House Republicans released a continuing resolution (CR) bill proposing to cut $100B from FY11 budget. How did the National Science Foundation (NSF) fare?

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 1 Comment

Innovate or perish? Not so fast

Kevin Lynch is back lecturing in the Financial Post on what Canada’s researchers need to do to solve the country’s economic woes, and reminiscing about his own days in government, when he was essentially running the country’s S&T agenda before … Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 3 Comments

Buying $190 million worth of excellence

At the invitation of U. Alberta’s President, Indira Samarasekera, the who’s who of Canada’s political, business, academic, and media elite converged yesterday on the Fairmont Chateau Laurier in Ottawa to celebrate the establishment of the Canada Excellence Research Chair Program (CERC). The official … Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 4 Comments

How relevant is an author’s citation index?

As I was scratching my head trying to find new criteria to add to the NSERC formula for “binning” Canadian scientists, I contemplated adding an “Author’s Citation Index”.  The thought didn’t last long.

Posted in R&D Policy | 4 Comments

Words to avoid when you are writing a research grant proposal

They are: “success, culture, media, games, social norms, lawyers, museum, leisure, stimulus.” I kid you not!

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 1 Comment

Move over G5 and G13, here come the Colleges

With the increasing trend towards funding non-peer reviewed research, it was only a matter of time before everyone got in on the action. The colleges are the latest entry into what is becoming a packed field. And, the growing influence … Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 4 Comments

All the numbers you wanted to know but you were afraid to ask

Here is a comprehensive set of statistics on the 2010 NSERC Discovery Grants Program competition. This extensive report was prepared by NSERC and includes tables and figures that provide summary information on the 2010 competition, but also a few comparisons … Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | Leave a comment

NSERC’s Discovery Grants: The numbers by discipline

Many thanks to our colleague David Wehlau, Professor of Mathematics at Queen’s University, for compiling the following data comparing average Discovery Grants, their numbers, as well as the available funding for each of the NSERC-supported disciplines.  The data, which covers … Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | 4 Comments

NSERC’s “Binning system”: The word itself makes me cringe

… wrote a Canadian scientist describing reactions to the posts of “Piece of Mind” on NSERC’s new evaluation system. I am reproducing (with his/her permission) the following email: You are definitely not alone!

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | Leave a comment

Thought-provoking? Lunch room talk? Or both?

“I find your blog thought-provoking,” was one of the most pleasing comments I received since the beginning of this blog. Another colleague wrote: “It is very easy for people to become complacent and simply accept the sorts of changes that … Continue reading

Posted in Op-eds, R&D Policy | Leave a comment